South Naples Citrus Grove Future Uncertain as County Commission Continues Talks

One of South Naples’ last remaining citrus groves is at the center of a high-stakes land-use debate — and for now, its future remains undecided.

Collier County commissioners have delayed a final vote on a proposal that would rezone roughly 169 acres along Sabal Palm Road to allow residential development. The request could permit up to 423 homes, including a portion designated as income-restricted housing. Instead of approving or denying the plan outright, commissioners opted to continue discussions and give stakeholders more time to negotiate possible changes.

The property has operated as a working citrus grove for decades and stands as one of the last visible reminders of Collier County’s agricultural roots. But like many citrus operations across Florida, the grove has faced mounting challenges in recent years — including citrus greening disease, rising labor costs and shifting market pressures that have made long-term farming increasingly difficult.

Supporters of redevelopment argue that the grove is no longer economically sustainable and that the land represents an opportunity to help address the region’s growing housing demand. Southwest Florida continues to see strong population growth, and proponents say adding residential units — particularly with some affordable options — could provide relief in an increasingly tight housing market.

Opponents, however, say the proposal raises significant environmental and infrastructure concerns.

The grove borders environmentally sensitive areas near conservation lands and forest habitat. Residents and environmental advocates have voiced concerns about potential impacts to wildlife corridors, stormwater management and water quality. Others worry about traffic increases along Sabal Palm Road and whether surrounding infrastructure can handle additional density.

During recent commission meetings, dozens of residents spoke during public comment, reflecting deep community interest in the outcome. Some urged commissioners to protect the grove as open space or seek conservation alternatives. Others emphasized the importance of balancing property rights with responsible growth.

Rather than drawing a firm line, commissioners signaled they want more information and potential compromise. The delay allows time for the developer, community groups and county staff to explore modifications that could address environmental safeguards, density adjustments or design changes.

At its core, the citrus grove debate reflects a broader question facing Collier County: how to manage growth while preserving the rural character and natural assets that define much of South Naples.

With development pressure continuing across Southwest Florida, decisions like this one carry weight beyond a single parcel of land. The outcome could influence future rezoning requests and signal how aggressively — or cautiously — the county approaches growth in sensitive areas.

For now, the citrus trees remain standing, and the final decision remains pending. Commissioners are expected to revisit the proposal at a future meeting after additional dialogue and review.

In a county where farmland, conservation and development often intersect, the future of the South Naples Citrus Grove may become one of the defining land-use stories of 2026.