Naples’ Five Best Pizza Spots—And One Worthy Honorable Mention

Naples is known for Gulf sunsets and fine dining, but locals know our pizza scene rivals any big city. To find the true standouts, we analyzed average star ratings, total review counts, and consistency of praise across Yelp, TripAdvisor, and Google. We focused on restaurants with at least several hundred reviews so a single good or bad night wouldn’t skew the results.

The result is a data-driven ranking of Naples’ favorite pizzerias—each with a signature pie that keeps locals coming back.

1. San Giuseppe Pizza

2400 Vanderbilt Beach Rd., Unit 104
Family-owned and universally loved, San Giuseppe tops every review platform with its slow-fermented dough and perfectly balanced sauce. The square Grandma Pizza—cheese beneath the sauce, finished with a drizzle of pesto—is a local legend.

2. Twisted Sheep Pizza & Brew

3802 Tamiami Trail E.
Equal parts pizzeria and craft-beer playground, Twisted Sheep wins raves for bold flavors and a lively atmosphere. Try the Backyard BBQ with smoky pulled pork or the fiery Buffalo Chicken paired with one of their rotating IPAs.

3. Rosedale Brick Oven

1427 Pine Ridge Rd.
A true wood-fired experience: thin crusts blistered to perfection and topped with San Marzano tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. The classic Margherita is the crowd favorite, while the Napoli with prosciutto and arugula adds a peppery punch.

4. Cosmos Ristorante & Pizzeria

536 Tamiami Trail N.
Cosmos blends Neapolitan tradition with a warm, family vibe. Their Cosmos Special, stacked with Italian meats and vegetables, shows why this trattoria-style spot has become a staple for locals and visitors alike.

5. Rosati’s Pizza

1201 Piper Blvd. & 818 Neapolitan Way
Chicago roots meet Florida sunshine. Rosati’s thin crust and deep dish both get high marks, with the Sausage & Pepperoni Combo often called the best of both worlds.

Honorable Mention: New York Pizza & Pasta

11140 Tamiami Trail N., plus additional Naples locations

While aggregate numbers place these five just ahead, New York Pizza & Pasta is a Naples institution worthy of special recognition. Decades of loyal customers rave about its foldable New York–style slices, the square Grandma Pie, and a decadent White Pizza with ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic. Its staying power and neighborhood feel make it a beloved part of the city’s pizza culture.

These rankings reflect a true cross-section of public opinion: high star ratings, hundreds of reviews, and consistent praise for flavor, service, and value. Whether you’re chasing a wood-fired Margherita or a Chicago deep dish, Naples offers a slice for every craving—plus a homegrown classic in New York Pizza & Pasta that locals will never stop loving.