Collier County to Display Ten Commandments in Government Buildings Despite Opposition

Commission Approves a Controversial Historical Display

In a 4–1 vote, the Collier County Commission approved placing the Ten Commandments alongside the Declaration of Independence, Bill of Rights, and U.S. Constitution in historical displays at three county-owned buildings—explicitly excluding schools. The donation of framed copies will come from a private citizen. Commissioners argue that the display is meant to reflect historical influence on American legal principles, not to endorse a religious agenda.

Public Pushback: Inclusive Values at Stake

Despite the stated historical intent, the display ignited vigorous opposition. During public comment, roughly 39 residents weighed in—most against the measure. One speaker emphasized that Collier County belongs to people of all beliefs and warned that government alignment with one faith could weaken collective liberty. Concerns also arose over different religious traditions interpreting the Ten Commandments in divergent ways.

Legal Justification: A Document, Not a Doctrine

Commissioner Chris Hall, who spearheaded the recommendation, stressed that the Ten Commandments would join other foundational texts, and his legal counsel confirmed the move wouldn't violate church-state separation laws. Courts have upheld similar displays when religious documents are grouped with secular ones. Only Commissioner Burt Saunders voted against the measure, arguing the Ten Commandments should remain in personal or religious spaces, not public buildings.

A Broader Debate on Heritage, History, and Inclusion

Supporters framed the display as recognizing moral foundations that informed U.S. law. Some echoed historical context rather than spiritual intent. Yet critics questioned this interpretation, citing founding figures like Madison and Jefferson who championed a firm boundary between religion and governance.

Others suggested that including excerpts from religious traditions like Islam could foster a more inclusive representation of moral heritage.

What’s Next: Details Still Being Finalized

With approval granted, next steps include deciding which county buildings will host the displays and how many will be installed. Those decisions are set to be handled by the county’s administration and attorney’s office. Meanwhile, discussions about the balance between celebrating history and respecting religious diversity are likely to continue among Collier residents.